reviews of tacos!

Tacos el Idolo

New York NY (Greenwich Village)

6th ave & w 4th st, new york NY 10012
yelp (different location)

Tacos El Idolo

thumb read some more of these great taco reviews! read some general articles about taco consumption find out more about tacosmog, and get in contact with the creators go back to the tacosmog mainpage thumbthumbthumbthumbthumbthumb

Rating: 80
Price: $$$

Having recently quit my job, I have ample time to wander the streets in these last few days before I head home to the Seattle suburbs. On a cold Saturday, I went out on a mission to pay my rent and see some Christmas lights - two of my favorite activities. After rent-paying failure (turns out the office is closed on Saturdays, as I perhaps should have guessed) and a fairly impressive Washington Square Park tree viewing, I was heading over to the subway station to check out the Columbus Circle lights and pay a visit to business associate Fred and Jessie's place. As I walked, I was vaguely contemplating life and tacos and which I enjoyed more. All of a sudden, Tacos el Idolo appeared on my side of 6th Ave, shining like a gemstone in a field of anthracite. I am fairly certain, from frequent biking along 6th Ave, that this is not a regular location for Tacos el Idolo, so good luck finding them in the future!

After several moments of needless hemming and hawing, I decided to go with one chivo (goat) taco - unfortunately, I had eaten a large quesadilla immediately before leaving the house, so I was not particularly hungry. El Idolo had a great selection of 11 different meats, as well as a big menu with some impressive deals (tamales for only $1.50!!). The options were, on the whole, more appealing than the menus at a lot of sit-down restaurants, and located much more conveniently to my current location.

The taco came out after a brief wait, garnished with lettuce, onion, and cilantro, and radishes and lime on the side. The meat was 'A' quality - adequate and average. My chivo was very salty, almost to the point that it could have been anything under there. However, it was nicely grilled (perfect for a cold day) and the flavor was boosted a lot by the addition of a lime. There were two salsa options, both potent: an overpoweringly smoky red and a sharp green with a tart aftertaste. Both were lacking in subtlety of flavor, but were a welcome addition to the taco. On the whole, El Idolo was just about average in every respect - though I will likely return to give the tamales a try.

Reviewed by tacosmog.com on